The electoral college - mackenzie marquess professor beange govt 2305 23 october 2013 electoral college outline the electoral college is a system that elects the president, it is possible for a presidential candidate to win the popular votes of the citizens and still lose the election because of the electoral college, a prime example of this rare happening is the election of 2000 where george. What is the main idea of the introduction this is important to understand because we will be reading arguments for or against the electoral college how did the twelfth amendment affect the electoral college they each focus on different problems caused by the electoral college in argument one, the author cites several different. Black also fails to recognise the fact that the electoral college acts as a buffer against a few more populated states taking total control of the country and its governance as a result. Best answer: the argument against the electoral college is made by a combination of people who don't understand it, and those who oppose our current form of government and seek to change it to learn how the electoral college works read article ii of the u s constitution to understand it study article ii of the u s constitution.
National popular will, the argument goes, the electoral college reinforces a two- party system, discourages third-party or independent candidates, and thereby tends to restrict choices available to the electorate. Opponents of the electoral college are further concerned about its possible role in depressing voter turnout their argument is that, since each state is entitled to the same number of electoral votes regardless of its voter turnout, there is no incentive in the states to encourage voter participation. The electoral college is a hybrid of direct democracy no candidate would have won without the popular vote the ec works on a confusing mix of politics and the public vote is a key part of that con doesn't seem to get that voting for electors and joe schmoe is basically the same thing.
The best arguments against the electoral college by diana pope - dec 23 2016 10 shares the electoral college is an integral part of the presidential elections however, many americans don't agree with the processes behind this complex voting system. The idea is that once enough states buy in, the electoral votes that are actually coming from the popular vote would exceed 270 and circumvent the electoral college without ever changing the. The whole purpose of the electoral college was to have politically savvy people deciding who the next president would be, rather than the general public because the founding fathers understood that the general public, for the most part, is out of touch with the inner workings of the federal government.
In 2008 distinctive court situations have been filed in an attempt to stay away from the electoral college from counting the votes till 0bama replaced into appropriate vetted, however the court situations have been handed over as have been hundreds of telephone calls from outraged parts. Why national popular vote is a bad idea bulwark against mass hysteria and the hysteria created by mass media owes itself not to the existence of the electoral college's indirect method. The electoral college is the body that casts the official votes in the p residential election process, and that vote is based on the results of the popular vote from each state in this task , students will learn about the presidential election process and argue for or against the use of the electoral college. Problems with the equal protection argument against “winner take all” in the electoral college last week congress tallied the votes cast by the electoral college and officially declared.
The rural argument against the electoral college by transportprovidence on november 30, 2016 the electoral count, barring any changes that might happen after a recount is completed. College students first learning about the electoral college will often defend the system by citing its original purpose: to provide a check on the public in case they make a poor choice for president. The electoral college was created for the very reason it worked this year: 1 to ensure equal voting strength for all areas and people’s of this amazing country 2.
Us government ch13 study play one of the major flaws in the electoral college system is that the winner of the popular vote is not guaranteed for presidency the plan by which a presidential vacancy is filled which of the following statements is not an argument against the electoral college system. Federalist no 68 is the 68th essay of the federalist papers, and was published on march 12, 1788 it is probably written by alexander hamilton under the pseudonym publius , the name under which all of the federalist papers were published.
The electoral college really does give less power to certain areas around the country it magnifies the importance of crucial swing states like ohio and iowa , which are disproportionately white. Ron sargent - 10/31/2004 you don't address the rural-urban divide, and using the electoral college as a tool to provide balance between the two. The idea of the winner take all system is that if you win a district or a state or whatever body of constituents it may be, then you take all of those electoral votes electoral votes accumulate and once a certain threshold is broken by a candidate then they are declared the winner.